She is usually calling the shots in the courtroom, but a new lawsuit has put Judge Judy Sheindlin in the hot seat. On Jan. 19, Kaye Switzer and the trust of the late Sandi Spreckman, two producers who were responsible for bringing Judge Judy to TV in 1996, filed suit against Judy, Big Ticket Television, and CBS over syndication profits. “It all hinged on Judy raking in a whopping $95 million-plus for her back catalog of shows last August,” a source exclusively tells Closer Weekly. “Kaye, along with Sandi’s estate, believed they were being left high and dry by the deal.”

Judy, 75, is one of the highest-paid TV personalities, earning $47 million last year. After she agreed to sell the Judge Judy library to CBS, the lawsuits over money started rolling in. But Judy isn’t stressed about the outcome. “She believes the show became this monster success off the sweat of her own brow and the force of her personality,” says an insider. “Who is owed what is just background noise to her.”

judge judy walk of fame getty images

While the insider notes Judy “was always fond” of Kaye and Sandi, the fact is they were fired by the show’s production company before Judge Judy ever made it on the air. What they’re fighting for now is the five percent of the $95 million library deal — $4.75 million — they claim their original contract gave them. “Judy still has warm feelings toward Kaye and the memory of Sandi,” the insider explains. “But she just doesn’t see this as her fight.” So the woman famous for sayings like, “I’m the boss, Applesauce,” appears to be taking the lawsuit in stride. “Judy never entered a contract with Kaye and Sandi personally,” the source says. “Whatever piece of the pie the gals got was out of Judy’s hands.” In other words, it’s not for her to judge.

For more on Judge Judy, pick up the latest issue of Closer Weekly, on newsstands now — and be sure to sign up for our newsletter for more exclusive news!