We’ve got some interesting Hollywood dating news! Fifty Shades of Grey star Dakota Johnson is reportedly seeing Mad Men actor Jon Hamm after the two were recently spotted drinking wine at Kingside restaurant in NYC. A witness reportedly told Page Six that “they seemed to really be enjoying each other’s company,” which of course means we can expect an engagement announcement any day now. (Kidding, of course!)

Though we don’t know much more about the surprising encounter, we’d like to imagine that Jon, famed for playing ’60s ad man and lothario Don Draper, was sipping a whiskey on the rocks, and that Dakota, famed for playing skittish, prim Anastasia Steele, kept tripping over her words and spilling her drink. The two were first seen enjoying each other’s company at Elton John’s 70th birthday, of all places, where they no doubt bonded over a mutual love of the legend’s greatest hits and felt “The Love Tonight.” (Sorry, not sorry).

Dakota previously dated British rocker Matthew Hitt, the frontman of the Drowners, while Jon split with his longtime love, Jennifer Westfeldt, in 2015. “With great sadness, we have decided to separate, after 18 years of love and shared history. We will continue to be supportive of each other in every way possible moving forward,” the former couple said in a statement at the time. If Dakota and Jon are a new couple, they would be one of the weirdest celebrity hook-ups ever — guess we’ll just have to wait and see if they’re the real deal!

This post was written by Rebecca Cope. It originally appeared on our sister site, Grazia Daily.